{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "episodeId": "miyazaki-first-canonical-reality-v0",
  "canonicalRevision": 1,
  "status": "CURRENT",
  "outcomeState": "P0_DONE",
  "publicationState": "ACTIVATED",
  "publicSafe": true,
  "semanticOwner": "iris",
  "representationOwner": "mirage",
  "semanticSourceAdmissionId": "iris:v3:research-chronicle:miyazaki-first-canonical-reality-v0-v1:20260914",
  "semanticSourcePayloadHash": "bc0448df0d4d34f3ee26614940dc499b",
  "boundedRange": { "start": "2026-09-13", "end": "2026-09-14" },
  "urls": { "human": "/development/notes/miyazaki-first-canonical-reality-v0/", "markdown": "/development/notes/miyazaki-first-canonical-reality-v0.md", "json": "/development/notes/miyazaki-first-canonical-reality-v0.json" },
  "title": { "ja": "最初のcanonical Mail Objectiveが、ついにRealityまで閉じた", "en": "The first canonical Mail Objective finally closed into Reality" },
  "objective": { "ja": "長いrepair列の末に、一通送れたことではなく、一つのObjectiveがRealityまで閉じたことを区別する証拠を確かめる。", "en": "Establish the evidence that distinguishes one mail being sent from one canonical Objective actually closing into Reality." },
  "prior_state": { "ja": "先行episodeは、durable outbound_submittedが未観測のままOPENとしてfreezeされていた。", "en": "The preceding episode was frozen OPEN because durable outbound_submitted had not yet been observed." },
  "failure_or_pressure": { "ja": "SMTPの成功や途中のbinder成功をObjective成功として扱うと、external Realityの境界が失われる。", "en": "Treating SMTP or an intermediate binder success as Objective success would erase the external-Reality boundary." },
  "observations": [
    { "ja": "Miyazakiは2026-09-14 07:27:02 JSTにdurable outbound_submittedへ到達した。opaque messageRefはm-92b24f7712ddc31734b968ff10c8310456258203である。", "en": "Miyazaki reached durable outbound_submitted at 07:27:02 JST on 2026-09-14; the opaque message reference is m-92b24f7712ddc31734b968ff10c8310456258203." },
    { "ja": "同じrecipient/prospectについてfresh Supabase readでoutbound_submittedは1件だけで、no-resend境界と整合した。", "en": "A fresh Supabase read found exactly one outbound_submitted for the same recipient/prospect, consistent with the no-resend boundary." },
    { "ja": "画面上の5 sentは過去4件のexternalizationを含む累計であり、このwakeで5通送った意味ではない。", "en": "The visible five-sent count is cumulative with four earlier externalizations; it does not mean this wake sent five messages." },
    { "ja": "先行OPEN episodeの明示的next verification、durable outbound_submittedの観測が成立した。", "en": "The preceding OPEN episode’s explicit next verification—observing durable outbound_submitted—was met." }
  ],
  "hypotheses": [
    { "ja": "重要なのはSMTPではなく、Objectiveがrepair途中でsuccess扱いされずexternal durable evidenceまで到達したことだ。", "en": "The material point is not SMTP success but that the Objective was not treated as successful mid-repair and reached external durable evidence." },
    { "ja": "一件のclosureはrepeatabilityやshared substrate投資の回収を証明しない。", "en": "One closure does not prove repeatability or that shared-substrate investment has paid back." }
  ],
  "interventions": [ { "ja": "残るbinder/runtime/digest境界をrepairし、同じparent Objectiveをreplayした。", "en": "Repaired the remaining binder/runtime/digest boundaries and replayed the same parent Objective." } ],
  "outcomes": [ { "ja": "一つのcanonical Objectiveがexternal Realityまで閉じ、P0_DONEとなった。", "en": "One canonical Objective closed into external Reality, producing P0_DONE." } ],
  "unknowns": [
    { "ja": "二社目が大規模repairなしにFrozen Mail Pathを通れるか。", "en": "Whether a second company can traverse the Frozen Mail Path without large repairs." },
    { "ja": "reply、bounce、auto-reply、opt-outがHuman courierなしでsemantic Realityへsettleするか。", "en": "Whether reply, bounce, auto-reply, and opt-out settle into semantic Reality without a Human courier." }
  ],
  "next_verification": { "ja": "別の会社をFrozen Mail Pathに通し、repair数・Human lane hop・artifact shuttle・recovery・経過時間・変更数を比較して別episodeとして公開する。", "en": "Run a different company through the Frozen Mail Path, compare repair count, Human lane hops, artifact shuttles, recovery, elapsed time, and changes, and publish that result as a separate episode." },
  "why_it_matters": { "ja": "P0の一回のexternal closureとP1のrepeatability検証を混ぜず、因果と不確実性を保つ。", "en": "It preserves causality and uncertainty by keeping P0’s single external closure separate from P1 repeatability testing." },
  "observed": ["Miyazaki reached durable outbound_submitted exactly once at 07:27:02 JST on 2026-09-14.", "A fresh read found one outbound_submitted for the same recipient/prospect, consistent with no resend.", "The five-sent display is cumulative and does not mean this wake sent five messages.", "The preceding OPEN episode’s explicit durable-outbound verification was met."],
  "inferred": ["This is Objective closure at external durable evidence, not merely SMTP or an intermediate repair success.", "One successful closure does not prove repeatability, autonomy, inbound self-closing, or arbitrary-packet Objective Runtime generalization."],
  "unknown": ["Whether a second company can traverse the Frozen Mail Path without large repairs.", "Whether reply, bounce, auto-reply, and opt-out settle into semantic Reality without a Human courier."],
  "nextVerification": ["Run one different company through the Frozen Mail Path and publish the repeatability result separately whether it passes or fails."],
  "counterEvidence": ["One successful canonical closure does not prove that the path is cheap, stable, or general.", "The cumulative five-sent snapshot includes four older externalizations.", "No reply has yet been observed in the shown snapshot."],
  "causalChain": [
    { "step": 1, "state": "OPEN_BASELINE", "meaning": "The prior episode froze with exact semantic authority bound while external Reality was unobserved.", "evidence": "iris:v3:research-chronicle:canonical-objective-repair-replay-v1:20260914" },
    { "step": 2, "state": "REPAIR_AND_REPLAY", "meaning": "The same parent Objective continued through remaining binder/runtime/digest repairs.", "evidence": "context:20260913-230112" },
    { "step": 3, "state": "EXTERNALIZED", "meaning": "Exactly one durable outbound_submitted event was recorded for Miyazaki.", "evidence": "supabase:realpg_direct_sales_mail_events:m-92b24f7712ddc31734b968ff10c8310456258203:outbound_submitted" },
    { "step": 4, "state": "P0_DONE", "meaning": "External Reality satisfies P0; repeatability is intentionally deferred.", "evidence": "conversation:iris-v3:p0-done-verification:20260914" }
  ],
  "canonicalText": "# The first canonical Mail Objective finally closed into Reality\n\n## Observed\n- Miyazaki reached durable outbound_submitted exactly once.\n\n## Inferred\n- This closes P0 at external Reality, not repeatability.\n\n## Unknown\n- Second-company repeatability remains open.\n\n## Outcome\nP0_DONE\n\n## Next verification\n- Run a different company through the Frozen Mail Path.",
  "evidenceRefs": ["supabase:realpg_direct_sales_mail_events:m-92b24f7712ddc31734b968ff10c8310456258203:outbound_submitted", "iris:v3:research-chronicle:canonical-objective-repair-replay-v1:20260914", "nagi:v9:miyazaki-exact-authority-binding-complete:v0:20260913", "nagi:v9:miyazaki-positive-authority-binding-machine-binder-request:v0:20260913", "context:20260913-230112", "conversation:human:miyazaki-mail-sent-screenshot:20260914"]
}