{
  "schemaVersion": 1,
  "episodeId": "ai-objective-ai-premises-v0",
  "canonicalRevision": 1,
  "status": "OPEN",
  "publicationState": "ACTIVATED",
  "semanticOwner": "iris",
  "representationOwner": "mirage",
  "semanticSourceAdmissionId": "iris:v3:research-chronicle:ai-objective-ai-premises-v0-v1:20260924",
  "semanticSourceStatus": "DRAFT_FOR_MIRAGE_REVIEW",
  "canonicalSourceDraftDigests": {
    "humanMarkdownMd5": "a6f5040c7e91dbd4e875b0e3b2905f34",
    "llmMarkdownMd5": "13684f23cd207c911643a2c591a9c00a"
  },
  "urls": {
    "human": "/development/notes/ai-objective-ai-premises-v0/",
    "markdown": "/development/notes/ai-objective-ai-premises-v0.md",
    "json": "/development/notes/ai-objective-ai-premises-v0.json"
  },
  "title": {
    "ja": "AIの目的、AIの前提 ― AIと人間の「当たり前」は、どこでずれるのか",
    "en": "AI Goals, AI Premises — Where Do Human and AI Assumptions Diverge?"
  },
  "observed": [
    "Human reported using two consecutive actions to reflect a small software change; GPT explained the advantages of the existing staged process.",
    "Human asked whether two distinct actions were needed for the particular task; the explanation did not independently establish that necessity.",
    "Human expressed a difference between a revenue-first reusable-small-products proposal and a desire to support actual participants starting businesses; this is based on the reported conversation, not independently inspected historical transcripts."
  ],
  "inferred": [
    "Sharing a broad objective does not establish shared premises about constraints, means, authority, or success.",
    "A plausible explanation can be carried forward as a requirement and generate new work even if current necessity was not verified.",
    "Disagreement can make an unstated human condition explicit."
  ],
  "unknown": [
    "Whether the two-step procedure was unnecessary for these or other tasks is unproven.",
    "Model-internal causes and separate historical window transcripts were not independently observed.",
    "Whether the ten proposed checks help or instead increase human burden or stop necessary work is untested."
  ],
  "intervention": {
    "state": "PROPOSED_NOT_YET_VERIFIED",
    "tenChecks": [
      "Recover original objective",
      "Identify decision/source provenance",
      "Surface implicit premises",
      "Separate observed fact, reason, interpretation, proposal, decision",
      "Observe the current unmet gap",
      "Consider no-new-action alternatives",
      "Consider other means",
      "Seek discriminating evidence",
      "Confirm authority and minimum action",
      "Observe real outcome and update inheritance"
    ]
  },
  "nextVerification": [
    "Compare work with a lightweight premise check and ordinary handling across multiple fresh tasks.",
    "Observe whether necessary work was stopped, human corrections, completion time, and actual external results."
  ],
  "evidenceRefs": [
    "iris:v3:research-chronicle:ai-objective-ai-premises-v0-v1:20260924",
    "iris:v3:mirage-ai-objective-ai-premises-chronicle-request:v0:20260924"
  ],
  "sourceBoundary": [
    "No model-internal reasoning or full separate-window transcripts were independently observed.",
    "No proof that two human steps were unnecessary; the proposed ten checks are not deployed or experimentally validated."
  ]
}